ChoralNet logo German language version

Spanish language version

French language version
HOME   
Resources and communications for the global choral community
About ChoralNet
Community
Choir Directory
Lists
Forums
Classifieds
Repertoire
Composers
Rehearsal
Voice
Text and Language
Church Music
Education
Performance
Technology
Multimedia
Reference
Choral Accessories
Submit a Link
Site Map
Contact Us

ChoralBlog

All views expressed are those of the author only

Sculpture of the day

by Allen H Simon (February 4, 2007)


This sculpture by Scottish artist Lotte Glob is entitled Choir, part of a sculpture garden in the Loch Eribol region. She writes:

Living and working in the Far Northern Highlands of Scotland for the past forty years, I have come to the realization that my work has an identity with nature, a belonging with nature, whether in a small garden or in a vast landscape or just between plants in a window box. My creative process involves a close, continuing and intense relationship with the landscape and wilderness of the Scottish Highlands, a part of which is long hikes into the mountains, bringing back materials such as rocks and sediments to incorporate into my work.

Responses (0)

Feral Choir

by Allen H Simon (February 2, 2007)

Feral Choir leader taps the wilder side of vocal music.

It’s true that vocal ensembles are inherently social organizations; savagery is one quality that’s usually missing from their makeup. But Minton’s aim is to usher the wild and the uncanny into the realm of vocal music
Gotta love the phrase "Feral choir".

Responses (0)

Opera composer Menotti dies at 95

by Philip Copeland (February 2, 2007)

It is sad to note the passing of opera composer Menotti, who died yesterday.

From a news source:

"He died pretty peacefully and without any pain. He died in my arms," said his adopted son, Francis Menotti, by telephone from Monte Carlo.

The Italian composer won Pulitzers for a pair of the 20th century's more successful operas: "The Consul," which premiered in 1950 in Philadelphia, and "The Saint of Bleecker Street," which opened at New York's Broadway Theater in 1954. "The Consul" also earned him the New York Drama Critics Circle award as the best musical play of the year in 1954.

He also wrote the Christmas classic "Amahl and the Night Visitors" for NBC, which was broadcast in 1951 and may have been the first opera written for television. Menotti also authored the libretto for "Vanessa," which was composed by Samuel Barber, and revised the libretto for Barber's "Antony and Cleopatra." In addition to working together, Barber and Menotti shared a house in Mount Kisco, N.Y., north of New York City, for many years.


http://www.al.com/search/index.ssf?/base/news/1170412278135990.xml?birminghamnews?wire&coll=2

Like all experiences with great music, I feel like I had a connection with Menotti because I participated in a production of one of his operas, The Saint of Bleeker Street. I was only the pianist for the piano-only production, but I gained insight into the composer and his compositional style.

Responses (1)

Singing in Swedish

by Philip Copeland (February 1, 2007)

My Chamber Choir is working on Som stjärnorna på himmelen by Wilhelm Peterson-Berger. It is a fabulous piece of music that I’ve loved for many years. I first heard the work at an ACDA Convention by the Mats Nilssons Vokalensemble and I’ve wanted to do it ever since.

I purchased the music for my choir several years ago and planned to perform it . . . but I never could get past the Swedish text.

Do you ever get intimidated into inaction by a foreign language? Or am I the only one? I pledged not to let it happen this year—the music is just too good. Three things are helping me conquer my "fear of the Swedish tongue."

1. This website gives recorded examples of Swedish vowel sounds and strange letter combinations.

2. A student suggested that I contact the international department at my university and find a Swedish student for help. Why hadn’t I thought of that before?

3. In doing a bit more research, I discovered an incredible recording of the art song by Anne Sofie von Otter. Before plugging the title into the Amazon search bar, I didn’t know that it was also an art song—and equally effective. Listening to Anne Sofie von Otter sing the work will probably help the most, in fact.

It's easy to sidestep works in unfamiliar languages; there are plenty of works in Latin and English. A little effort and investigation, however, might deliver a profound opportunity for you and your choir.

Responses (2)

Study: Brain Wired for Improvisation, Not Perfection?

by Cindy Pribble (January 31, 2007)

This article points to new brain research which suggests that our brains are more wired towards improvisation than perfection. This summary/abtract of a longer study:

http://www.webmd.com/content/Article/130/117870.htm

covers the physiological implications of our ease of learning something physical, like a golf swing. Do you think the findings might hold some clues about the relative ease of the learning physical act of singing correctly as well? And should perfection of the instrument be THE driving force?

For this discussion, I am defining the term 'perfection' as the product of the natural gifts of each singer having been brought to full potential.

We know students learn through consistent reinforcement of correct habits on the journey toward a more perfect instrument. If this is true, are changes implied for the choral instructor who feels s/he must teach all singing styles, all genres, some of which, in young singers, may work against the grain of the correct habit the teacher hopes to instill?

Should we grant more teaching time to repertoire which "perfects the instrument" as something foundational (the bottom line), or stretch the horizon to embrace a healthy balance of all styles and genres in order to have our singers "do it all" before age 21?

*If* improvisation is desirable and the natural state of how the brain learns , is it possible for young musicians to tap into that aspect of music if ALL that is taught is reinforcement of the basics?

Is a balance between improvisation and perfection desirable or even possible? How do you achieve it with your students?

Responses (0)

Glass Curtain

by Allen H Simon (January 30, 2007)

Betsy Grizzell writes on Chicago Classical Music about the "glass curtain" between the performers and audience.

Perfect Concerts. You know, the ones where the performers all dress the same, walk the same, look the same. Very Stepford. Very calculated. Someone obviously ordered up a glass curtain to make sure the audience is kept separate from the performance.

The Glass Curtain is a funny thing. In some performances, it’s there the whole time. I find that uncomfortable, maybe even boring. In some performances it comes and goes. I like this, especially in our CAC concerts. When you’ve got a jazz chart in front of you, you’d better drop everything and let ‘er rip. If it’s a Palestrina Mass, you can afford a feeling of “Excuse us, folks, there’s something we want to do amongst ourselves.”

I especially like a 2-way curtain. I love it when the audience feels comfortable enough to shout from their seats, or to wait around afterwards to tell us what they thought of a piece, even if they hated it.

Perfection is something that is never achieved, even behind a fancy Glass Curtain. So why try? Better to share. Better to invite the audience into the same room to hear what we have to offer. To look them straight in the eye with a smile or a tear.
There's a roaring debate going on in ChoralTalk right now about technical perfection vs expression, but this essay sums it up pretty well. There's no question that they work enormously hard at the various technical aspects of their music (if you've never sung vocal jazz, take my word for it that it's very difficult), but they aren't working on expression per se, rather just connecting with an audience.

As a conductor, I always feel in touch with the audience, even though I have my back to them. I know whether they're listening or reacting or bored without having to see them; it's something in the little rustles and the coughs and the creaking of seats as people cross and uncross their legs. It's in the pause in between the end of a piece and the beginning of the applause.

Although Betsy is in an unconducted group where she can make eye contact with the audience at all times, there's no reason our singers can't be aware of the audience without looking at them, just as we conductors are. And even without eye contact, we can be singing to them, rather than to ourselves. But it takes, for some singers, a pretty major change in viewpoint.

Responses (0)

Brother, can you spare a few cents?

by Allen H Simon (January 30, 2007)

Jonathan Miller, on Chicago Classical Music:

First and foremost: sing squarely in the middle of the pitch. Most bass notes work well with this rule, partly because most bass notes (at least in the stuff I sing) are the "roots" of their chords. Everyone lines up on top of your note. It's quite fun.

Of course, as soon as there is a rule there is an exception.

If you are singing a cappella, and the chord is in first inversion (i.e., the bass note is the *third* of the chord), you must pull the bass note up just a few hair-breadths.
After spending a couple of semesters studying tunings and temperaments in grad school, I still find this one of the great mysteries of choral music. We all bring the third of the chord higher in major triads because it seems more "in tune" than equal temperament, and yet a perfectly-tuned third (a 5:4 ratio) is actually smaller than an equal-tempered third, by a good fourteen cents (where a half-step is 100 cents). A Pythagorean third, created by ascending four perfectly-tuned fifths and descending two octaves, is a 81:64 ratio, a bit larger than an equal-tempered third, but it strains credulity that our ears can hear a frequency ratio like that.

Gerald Eskelin, director of the LA Jazz Choir, wrote in his fascinating book Lies My Music Teacher Told Me that thirds standing alone want to be tuned lower (i.e. to the 5:4 ratio) but thirds in a chord containing a fifth want to be higher.

Just one of those eternal mysteries, I guess.

Responses (0)

How to sight-read

by Allen H Simon (January 30, 2007)

Jocelyn Lavin of the Hallé Choir blog has some tips on sight-reading. Instant summary:

  1. Sight-read every chance you get
  2. Embrace the "loud and wrong" philosophy
  3. Sing on the beat, whatever happens
  4. Go through your part before starting to sing it
  5. Look ahead all the time
  6. Look at the other parts as well as your own
  7. Do words or dynamics and everything else while sight-reading
  8. Know your scales and key signatures
  9. Be aware of scale degrees
  10. Learn to sing intervals (less important than previous item)
  11. Know what beat of the bar you're on at all times
She's got further elaboration on each point. You might not agree with every detail, but the overall philosophy is great.

Responses (2)

Schoolchildren singing

by Allen H Simon (January 30, 2007)

Part of a fascinating new photo archive at the library of Congress:




Pie Town, New Mexico

There are thousands of color photographs from 1939-1945, and public domain, at least in the USA. Worthy of hours of browsing.

Responses (0)

Yale choir melee in SF

by Allen H Simon (January 28, 2007)

Here's the best summary I've seen so far:
http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?file=/c/a/2007/01/26/MNGMHNPLCM1.DTL.

SF Police are still investigating, so there's no official response from them yet.

Responses (0)

Milestone

by Allen H Simon (January 28, 2007)

A milestone for me: I performed in my very first voice recital yesterday. I know this is old hat to many choir directors, but I've never really learned to sing properly, despite a couple semesters' worth of lessons in grad school at Westminster Choir College. But I have found myself teaching others to sing on a regular basis as a choir director (there's a lot of group vocal instruction in choir directing, as we all know), so when I had a chance, I decided to find out how to do it myself, so I could be a more effective instructor. I'll probably never be an opera star, but singing a recital along with seven or eight other adult students was an achievement for me. Who says old dogs can't learn new tricks?

We performed, among other things, Barber's 10-minute opera "A Hand of Bridge". Very entertaining, but rated PG-13.

Responses (1)

Save Your

by Allen H Simon (January 25, 2007)

This has always bugged me. Why do so many choirs pronounce "savior" as "save your"? No one says it that way, do they? I have the same question about "evil", pronounced "e-ville", but that doesn't come up as often.

Responses (5)

American Idol vs. music education

by Allen H Simon (January 20, 2007)

Tyler Skidmore writes:

Thought this article is interesting. You might want to throw this out into your Choralnet blog. Is American Idol destroying much of what we have done as music educators to encourage our students?

Or, maybe, do the negative comments encourage excellence? I doubt it.

Responses (10)

Conductor leads symphony into a black hole

by Allen H Simon (January 20, 2007)

God forbid I should ever get a review like this:

an object lesson in how an ineffective conductor can drag down a performance.
The conductor's
sloppy and incommunicative technique (and stunning lack of energy) resulted in performances which were shapeless, bleached out, at times a real train wreck.
The orchestra was rudderless, so much so that a number of its ace principal players missed entrance after entrance, clearly because Silverstein's cues were so unhelpful. There was no way to read his baton, to see and feel where the beat lay, so they guessed and guessed wrong.
The reviewer thought the piece, a newly-composed violin concerto, could have been very listenable with a good performance. But this was
a performance of exceptional disarray. Clunky cellos. Galumphing, vaguely in-tune horns. Messy tutti chords. Pretty much everything out of sync. The second movement, intended to evoke a blissful stasis, practically ground to a halt.

This one was beyond wobbly: [the conductor] couldn't locate a tempo and seemed to be waving his baton around for the heck of it.
The work was followed by a Dvorak symphony, which didn't go much better: "blown entrances", "sloppy climaxes", "out-of-tune playing". This is a professional symphony, even if it's not a top-rated one.
But [he] was failing to perform the most basic function of a conductor, to guide his musicians.
I told my wife that if I ever got a review like that, I'm definitely changing careers.

Responses (4)

Orthodox radio

by Allen H Simon (January 18, 2007)

http://ancientfaithradio.com

24 hours a day of Orthodox music, mostly choral. Who knew?

Responses (0)

Fifth episode of Trial by Choir

by Allen H Simon (December 28, 2006)

From the TLC website: "The chorus is racing to prepare for their first performance, but first they have to decide what to wear. Tony, Tim, and Duckie get solos in Jerome's new song. On the big day, Johnathan almost derails their triumph." [posted by David T.]

Responses (7)

Music Appreciation Christmas

by Allen H Simon (December 25, 2006)

When I was in graduate school, I often heard rumors of churches whose music directors subjected them to a "music appreciation Sunday," on which all music was eliminated: hymns were just recited, no organ, no choir, no sung liturgy. The idea was that the congregation would thereafter no longer take music for granted. I've never gotten a firsthand account of a church which actually did this, and it seems like a terribly manipulative idea for a music director to propose, but the fantasy is appealing.

This year I experienced something pretty close. While visiting relatives over Christmas, I attended their church for Christmas Eve, and it was a musical horror. The organist was a hack who couldn't play a single line of a hymn without multiple wrong notes. The standing-room-only congregation of about 500 didn't sing on hymns (even Christmas carols). (Admittedly it was a Catholic church.) The choir consisted of a couple of sopranos, a couple of altos who sang a third below whether it fit the harmony or not, and one baritone who droned along, usually an octave below the soprano; they treated every R as a vowel: "Angels we have HRRRRD on high...". The priest got out a guitar -- in the middle of the sermon -- and treated us to a rendition of "The Virgin Mary Had a Baby Boy" without any recognizable meter or key, although at least he had a decent singing voice. And this is in Minnesota, a region generally considered rich for choral music.

All this goes to remind me to appreciate the blessings of music I have available to me at home. If I'd stayed home and gone to my own church on Christmas Eve, I'd have heard Charpentier's "Messe de Minuit" with orchestra. After this, whenever I'm tempted to complain about music at my church, the memory of this Christmas will be there to remind me of what the alternatives are. Sometimes one needs a kick in the head.

Responses (8)

Dayspring

by Allen H Simon (December 23, 2006)

The new hymnal for the ELCA, the main Lutheran denomination in the USA, has a new version of the familiar Advent hymn "O Come, O Come Emmanuel."

The Good: They've added two verses so there's one corresponding with each of the O antiphons (the first verse repeats at the end for a total of eight verses). This hymn was always loosely based on the O antiphons, but there were traditionally only five verses. They've incorporated the O Antiphons into other propers for the season of Advent as well.

The Bad: they wrecked my favorite verse:

"O come, blest Dayspring, come and cheer
Our spirits by thine advent here."
Instead, it's now
"O Dayspring, come with light and cheer;
O Sun of justice, now draw near."
I don't mind losing the archaic "blest" and "thine", but it's a bummer to lose the word "advent," which is rare enough. I fear they think it's too obscure a word for the limited-English vocabulary they're using to strive for accessibility, but you'd think this would be a case where they'd want to preserve the meaning of the word, so that "Advent" doesn't become a meaningless word like "Lent" (i.e. only meaningful in a church context).

I suppose I should just be glad they kept "dayspring" rather than translating "oriens" literally as "morning star" or some such.

My church choir did the Kodaly arrangement of "Veni Emanuel" for Lessons & Carols this year. A very worthwhile arrangement, and pretty easy (it's only SAB).

Responses (0)

Fourth episode of Trial by Choir

by Allen H Simon (December 21, 2006)

According to the TLC website, tonight's episode (21 December) is titled "Still I Rise." Here's a link to the schedule page at the TLC website. However, when I checked my local listings, and those for some other locations, I couldn't find mention of this episode being shown. According to the local listings, the fifth episode might be shown on the 24th, and then repeated on the 28th. If you manage to watch tonight's episode, post your comments in this topic. [posted by David T.]

Responses (23)

Daniel Pinkham

by Allen H Simon (December 19, 2006)

...passed away yesterday at the age of 83. He had a very consistent and comprehensible approach to harmony, and a deft way with text setting, but his music never caught on, in my opinion because much of it is just too difficult. Much as I'd like to do "A Curse, A Lament, and A Vision" or "Fanfares", it would take too much rehearsal time in proportion to its audience appeal. While a few choral composers (such as Poulenc) can be difficult and still have enough box-office draw to be worth it, Pinkham never quite reached that level.

Of course, he did have a few less-difficult pieces, such as the Christmas Cantata and the Wedding Cantata, and my church choir did the bizarre "The Lord My Shepherd Is" (not bizarre because of music, but the strange Yoda-English of the psalm, with the verbs always stuck on the end of the lines). Maybe there are other good but not-difficult works that people can recommend. I'm surprised to see Musica lists 179 pieces by Pinkham.

Any such recommendations, or other reminiscences or comments about Pinkham, would be welcome.

Responses (4)

Third episode of Trial by Choir

by Allen H Simon (December 13, 2006)

"Sanctuary"

[description from TLC website] Jerome gives the chorus a goal. If they
can learn to sing a challenging Renaissance motet in Latin, without
accompaniment, they can move out of the basement into the church
sanctuary. The kids' rowdiness gets in the way, sparking major fireworks.

Responses (7)

Complaints Choir of Helsinki

by Allen H Simon (December 9, 2006)

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ATXV3DzKv68

Responses (2)

Second episode of Trial by Choir

by Allen H Simon (December 4, 2006)

Anything different?

Responses (33)

Trial by choir

by Allen H Simon (November 26, 2006)

I won't be seeing this, having no television, but feel free to comment on the TV show Trial by choir, premiering Nov. 26 on TLC.

Responses (95)

The Nursery Rhyme Police

by Allen H Simon (November 15, 2006)

In England, they treat the value of parents singing to their children seriously. Maybe too seriously?

Parents could be forced to go to special classes to learn to sing their children nursery rhymes, a minister said.

Those who fail to read stories or sing to their youngsters threaten their children's future and the state must put them right, Children's Minister Beverley Hughes said.
The ministry has developed a national curriculum for babies.
The threat of action against parents who fail to sing nursery rhymes was unveiled by Mrs Hughes as she gave the first details of Mr Blair's 'national parenting academy', a body that will train teachers, psychologists and social workers to intervene in the lives of families and become the 'parenting workforce'.

Mrs Hughes said that it was necessary for children to develop 'emotional intelligence and flexibility, and to have good problem-solving and interpersonal skills too.'

Responses (4)

ChoralNet's partners:
IFCM
IFCM
ACDA
ACDA
Chorus America
Chorus America
Rehearsal Arts
Rehearsal Arts
Small World MUSICFOLDER.com logo
Small World MUSICFOLDER.com
J. W. Pepper
J. W. Pepper
Help support ChoralNet by buying via these links:
or make a donation directly.

MUSICA repertoire database


Entire site copyright © 2008 ChoralNet, Inc.
ChoralNet Copyright Notice and Terms and Conditions of Use

Top of page - Home - Resources - Choirs - Search - Advertise
Partners: IFCM - ACDA - Chorus America - Rehearsal Arts - Small World MUSICFOLDER.com