• Sign In
  • ACDA.org
  • Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
ChoralNet

ChoralNet

The professional networking site for the global online choral community.

  • Home
  • Blog
  • ACDA News
  • Events
  • Community
    • Announcements
    • Classifieds

You are here: Home / Others / Plus ça change…

Plus ça change…

May 18, 2012 by Allen H Simon Leave a Comment


In case anyone tells you that the exclusion of music from the list of “real” academic subjects is a new invention, here’s a quote from Roman philosopher Seneca:
And what of those who are engaged in composing, hearing, and learning songs, while they twist the voice, whose best and simplest movement Nature designed to be straightforward, into the meanderings of some indolent tune, who are always snapping their fingers as they beat time to some song they have in their head, who are overheard humming a tune when they have been summoned to serious, often even melancholy, matters? These have not leisure, but idle occupation.
Writing on Joanne Jacobs’ excellent education blog, Diane Senechal has her high-school students read this letter from Seneca (which also condemns such frivolous activities as chess, sunbathing, spectator sports, and getting one’s hair cut) as a starting point for classroom discussion about such activities as Facebook and texting.

Filed Under: Others

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. John Howell says

    May 21, 2012 at 12:05 pm

    Allen:  I didn’t know that quote, so thanks!  However, two things to keep in mind.  First, the actual performance of music was at the bottom of the list for Greek philosophers–musica instrumentalis, as opposed to the much higher studies of musica mundana–the mathematical proportions represented in the heavens and demonstrated on the monochord–and musica humana–the proper agreement of the mind and body.  “Music” was thus part of the Quadrivium–the mathematical sciences–a concept picked up and transmitted by Boethius in the early 6th century and reflected in some European universities in which, to this day, music was a scholarly study and never a matter of practical music making.  If THAT’S all you want to do, go to conservatory, not university!
     
    And second, we have to remember that Seneca committed suicide at the order of the Emperor Nero, at least if we can trust the libretto of Monteverdi’s “Il coronatione di Poppea,” because he disapproved of the Emperor’s love life, so not everyone agreed with Seneca’s philosophical pronouncements!
     
    My parents were part of a long line of music educators who fought hard to get music into the public schools in the first place, and to get it recognized academically after that.  I would have been Valedictorian of my high school class, but our principal decided that I had “too many music credits.”  There is indeed nothing new about considering music–and ALL the arts–as “frills” and a place to save money in difficult economic times.
     
    John
    Log in to Reply
  2. Ronald Richard Duquette says

    May 21, 2012 at 6:38 am

    And philistines have been among us from the beginning….and it’s no easier to bear as a result.
     
    Ron
    Log in to Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

  • ACDA.org
  • The ChoralNet Daily Newsletter

Advertise on ChoralNet

Footer

Connect with us!

  • Home
  • About
  • Help
  • Contact Us
  • ACDA.org

Recent Blogs

  • Choral Ethics: Why Music?
  • ChoralEd, Performing Choral Music – Nigeria – Jude Nwankwo
  • The Conductor as Yogi: “The Only”
  • Choral Ethics: Being Grateful
  • Choral Ethics: Old School or New?

American Choral Directors Association

PO Box 1705
Oklahoma City, Oklahoma
73101-1705

© 2025 American Choral Directors Association. All rights reserved.
Terms of Use | Privacy Policy