• Sign In
  • ACDA.org
  • Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
ChoralNet

ChoralNet

The professional networking site for the global online choral community.

  • Home
  • Blog
  • ACDA News
  • Events
  • Community
    • Announcements
    • Classifieds

You are here: Home / Others / Choral Potpourri: Ethics Should Matter

Choral Potpourri: Ethics Should Matter

October 5, 2015 by Marie Grass Amenta Leave a Comment


                                                                          “We are all here on earth to help others; what on earth the others are here for I don’t know.” W. H. Auden
 
What does it mean to be an ethical choral conductor/director? Our own Choral Ethics code should be a model of behaviors for how we treat our singers, but shouldn’t it be a bit more? Don’t we need to be Choral Ethical to our colleagues in addition to our singers?
 
Vance*, who teaches at a community college and has a church job as well, has strong opinions on the subject and what it means to be ethical to our fellow choral colleagues. He believes being ethical in our profession means supporting each other with singers, recommendations, concert promotions, publicity, encouragement, and concert attendance. We may feel alone in our institutions and organizations; we are rarely alone in town. There are conductors in other schools and churches or nearby communities and he thinks developing a personal and congenial working relationship with them which is not just over the phone is important. Working together no matter the choral group you direct Vance believes is good, not just for the individual director, but for all directors and choral organizations in the community.
 
Vance also has opinions about what he considers to be unethical choral professionals. He has been left “holding the bag” a few times in his career, cleaning up messes—literally and figuratively–left by predecessors and has wanted to ask them one question: how can you leave a choral library in the shape you did? Leaving a disorganized choral library might not be considered unethical behavior by some and Vance realizes everyone has different standards as how exactly a choral library should be organized. However, we can all agree dumping a year’s worth of octavos collected at the end of the school year in one collective heap regardless of title and leaving it for your successor to take care of it not exactly the most stellar of behavior. Music dumping by his predecessor makes no sense to Vance, since now the guy looks like a big jerk to his former colleagues in the music department, in addition to his successor. Vance has gotten over it, but does wonder how the fellow is doing in his new position.
 
Maggie* has lived in her community for several decades. She’s made quite a name for herself, often being referred to as “a teacher’s teacher.” She is also a lovely person; with a history of taking a chance on singers no one else seems to want and turning them into excellent musicians. Or rather, her fine reputation is agreed upon by everyone except those in the local “premier” choral group and their director.
 
The chorale Maggie directs is a bit different from other community groups; it’s unique in that it focuses on a certain kind of ethic music. Her chorale is not in competition with any other group in the area but it doesn’t stop those in the “premier” choral group from taking verbal swipes at her and the chorale. All of the other community choral directors have spoken to her with their support, both together and individually, and feel she is being treated terribly. But it does make it difficult to invite her and her ensemble to the bi-annual local choral fest or to have a group meeting of local choral directors. They do what they can by making sure to invite her and her group to the fest or director meetings, but they can only do so much without causing trouble.
 
Maggie and her chorale attend local choral events when invited but sometimes wonders why they do. The “premier” group’s director is condescending or just plain rude and so are his singers. It’s very humiliating for her chorale to have to deal with this behavior in public and she is at a loss. Maggie wonders what to do because by attempting to make her look bad and behaving the way they do–without Choral Ethics–they are hurting their own organization, whether they realize it or not. It makes Maggie sad for our profession.
 
*Name Withheld
 
 

Filed Under: Others

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. Lucy Hudson Stembridge says

    October 7, 2015 at 1:34 pm

    Marie and Colleagues,
    I recall reading a profound article by an MENC president a few years ago:
     
            “We need to be in collaboration, rather than competition.”
     
    If we would all rise to this wisdom, we could have more excellence, and peace-hence-productivity in:
    1. Choirs
    2. Government
    3. Households/Families
    4. Schools
    5. Churches
    6. Neighborhoods
    7. The World
    8.  …maybe even Mars… 😉
     
    It is not difficult, but it does take committment and re-thinking our mindset.  A choir is an example of collabration, is it not?  Then may our community of director-teachers  reflect and act on the philosophy that we require of our members.
    I hope and pray that we will.
    Bles-Sings,
    -Lucy
    Log in to Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

  • ACDA.org
  • The ChoralNet Daily Newsletter

Advertise on ChoralNet

On This Day
August 8

William Hibbard, U. S. composer and educator, was born in Newton, Massachusetts, on this day in 1939.

Would you like to submit a blog post for consideration?

Are you interested in becoming a regular ChoralNet blogger? Please contact ACDA Director of Membership & Communications Sundra Flansburg at .

RSS JW Pepper

  • Shop Disney’s Encanto Sheet Music
  • How to Prepare for Your First Concert
  • How to Establish Classroom Routines and Why
  • 5 Things to Consider When Buying Color Guard Equipment
  • PYO Music Institute Presents the 9th Annual Ovation Award in Partnership with J.W. Pepper, Jacobs Music, and WRTI 90.1 FM
  • 10 Easy-To-Learn Funky Tunes for the Stands
  • Zoom F3 Field Recorder Review: The Easiest Way to Get Pro Audio for Your Music Ensembles
  • J.W. Pepper Names Eric King as New Chief Financial Officer
  • The Music Teachers’ Guide to Recording an Ensemble: The Samson C02 Mics Review
  • The Zoom Q8n-4K Handy Video Recorder Review

RSS NAfME

  • The Bipartisan Safer Communities Act: Providing for Safer Schools
  • Elevate Your Online Music Lessons
  • Ron Meers and John Stroube Honored as 2022 Lowell Mason Fellows
  • Believe in the Power of Great Teachers
  • NAfME Collegiate Chat: “Back to School: Starting Off on the Right Foot!”
  • NAfME Awards Shannon Kelly Kane Scholarships to Kelsey Zetzl of Butler University and Hannah Combs of Oakland University
  • 2022 African American Music Appreciation Month Resolution
  • NAfME Awards Four Collegiate Members and Seven Institutions’ Collegiate Chapters for Excellence and Achievement
  • CMA Foundation and NAfME Announce Three 2022 State Advocacy Award Grant Winners
  • NAfME Celebrates 50th Anniversary of NASPAAM with Resolution

Footer

Connect with us!

  • Home
  • About
  • Help
  • Contact Us
  • ACDA.org

Recent Blogs

  • An Interview with Duncan Tuomi, the Winner of the 2021 Raymond W. Brock Memorial Student Composition Competition
  • 7 Reasons Why Ordering Most Choral Music Is Ridiculous
  • Everyone CAN Get an A, But Not Everyone Will
  • Choral Potpourri/Choral Ethics: Scorched Earth
  • ChoralEd: Developing Choral Tone, Part 1

American Choral Directors Association

PO Box 1705
Oklahoma City, Oklahoma
73101-1705

© 2022 American Choral Directors Association. All rights reserved.
Terms of Use | Privacy Policy