• Sign In
  • ACDA.org
  • Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
ChoralNet

ChoralNet

The professional networking site for the global online choral community.

  • Home
  • Blog
  • ACDA News
  • Events
  • Community
    • Announcements
    • Classifieds

You are here: Home / Others / Boy Soprano Faces Discrimination

Boy Soprano Faces Discrimination

September 26, 2011 by Scott Dorsey Leave a Comment


YANKTON, SD – It’s every student’s dream to earn All-State honors. From the hardwood to the stage, those opportunities abound across KELOLAND. But one Yankton student was turned away because his talent breaks the rules for a state-sanctioned event.

The music flowing from these walls on Roberts Street is enough to make anyone want to stop and hear more. And what you’ll find here is a familiar sound to the Adam family.

14 year-old Garrett Adam is good at many things. Music is one of them.

“I play the flute and piccolo in the band,” Garrett said. “And I’ve been interested in singing a long time now, really interested in singing.”

He’s been in junior honor choir, band, marching band and more. And as a freshman this year at Yankton High School Garret had his sights set on an even bigger challenge: all-state chorus. He signed up under the part he sings every day in choir: Soprano.

“They let me walk in, I filled out the paper, gave it to her and she’s like, okay,” Garrett said.

“I was amazed that something like this could happen,” Garrett’s mom, Rochelle Adam, said. “Now. I can’t believe we’re dealing with this stuff now.”

Rochelle says that’s because two days after his audition, Garrett’s teachers pulled him aside and said he might not make all-state because according the state, guys don’t sing soprano.

“I was mad because when you say that you’re good enough and you’re not accepted, that’s just not right,” Garrett said.

“Discrimination is bad enough anyway in adults,” Rochelle said. “But when you do this to high school kids, high school is hard enough the way it is.”

 
Read the Complete Article.

Filed Under: Others

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. Jessica Rucinski says

    September 27, 2011 at 3:22 pm

    Okay, maybe girls can’t sing tenor, but in my experience every high school girl wants to sing soprano, not tenor. More importantly, “tenor” is not a natural voice part for a woman, whereas “soprano” is a perfectly natural voice part for a male with an unchanged voice. If the state musical organization would rather he sing tenor, then I’d say it should also allow female sopranos to sing tenor. Kudos to this boy for auditioning on his own voice part despite societal pressure to sound “manly” in high school…
    Log in to Reply
  2. Peter Hopkins says

    September 27, 2011 at 8:19 am

    I have an excellent 14 year old boy still singing soprano at my church (which has a boychoir program). He just entered a new high school as a ninth grader; they don’t allow boys to sing soprano or alto. I guess the teacher doesn’t want to deal with them until their voices have completely changed. The word for this is stupidity, it’s indefensible! His school schedule doesn’t let him participate in our boychoir anymore, but he has joined our adult choir, where he’ll be able to sing whatever voice part fits him at any time. His school choir has lost a RSCM-trained musician who has spent weeks singing in English cathedrals, is musically literate, and probably outsings any of the girls his age. “Late blooming” boys often have fantastic voices!
    Log in to Reply
  3. William R. Adams says

    September 27, 2011 at 7:00 am

    Scott,
     
    Thanks for posting this!  Sadly, the same thing is true here in Texas and I have had several of my [former] treble boys experience it.  I will also say, in fairness, that girls may not sing tenor either, per UIL rules.
     
    I am assumming that this ‘rule’ is nation wide? 
     
    I would like to hear some other thoughts/comments about this.  Anybody else have some information?
     
    Thanks,
     
    Bill Adams
    Fort Bend Boys Choir of Texas
    http://www.fbbctx.org
    Log in to Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

  • ACDA.org
  • The ChoralNet Daily Newsletter

Advertise on ChoralNet

Footer

Connect with us!

  • Home
  • About
  • Help
  • Contact Us
  • ACDA.org

Recent Blogs

  • Choral Ethics: Aftermath of Abuse
  • Between the Staves: Choral Questions, Candid Answers
  • Choral Ethics: Uncomfortable Blog Update
  • Choral Ethics: Uncomfortable Blog
  • ChoralEd, Fun Choral Warm-ups

American Choral Directors Association

PO Box 1705
Oklahoma City, Oklahoma
73101-1705

© 2026 American Choral Directors Association. All rights reserved.
Terms of Use | Privacy Policy