• Sign In
  • ACDA.org
  • Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
ChoralNet

ChoralNet

The professional networking site for the global online choral community.

  • Home
  • Blog
  • ACDA News
  • Events
  • Community
    • Announcements
    • Classifieds

You are here: Home / Others / Emotional Manipulation

Emotional Manipulation

December 9, 2010 by philip copeland Leave a Comment


This came from the Facebook page of my friend and colleague Eric Mathis at Samford University – a tale about emotional manipulation and music in the worship setting.
 
Here is when the truth hit home for one worship leader:
As a freshman at a Christian university, I spent the majority of that first year “church shopping.” I quickly became enamored with one of the church communities near my university campus; its seeker-sensitive approach, flashy light shows and blaring music created an exciting change of pace for a straight-laced pastor’s kid. The worship leader this particular morning nailed the Christian rock-star image: good looks, styled hair, faded jeans and an expensive acoustic guitar. About halfway through the second song, I noticed an unused microphone, which was set-up at approximately his waist level. “What purpose could that serve?” I wondered in a quick moment of curiosity, and then I quickly raised my hands and lost myself in the tunes. The sound was mixed wonderfully, the vocals were outstanding and the set of music was carefully constructed to serve as a powerful crescendo to the last song: “Hungry” by Kathryn Scott. As the leader belted out the final refrain—I’m falling on my knees, offering all of me—he acted on his words and literally fell to his knees. It was at this point that the aforementioned unused microphone came into play. It was preemptively placed at the perfect height and angle so the leader would be able to sing while on his knees without stopping his guitar-playing.
Later in the article, the author says this:
The image of a worship leader dramatically kneeling in front of a previously positioned microphone will be forever seared into my memory as an example of an over-the-top effort to elicit an emotional response. It was in this moment that I saw, for the first time in my life, the dangers of placing undue focus on the purely emotional aspect of corporate worship.
It is an important message for all church musicians, as well as an effective commentary on the most popular worship styles today.  Check out the whole article here.

Filed Under: Others

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. Susan Nace says

    December 13, 2010 at 5:45 pm

    I have a similar story.  In the 70s, I was a musician at a fundamentalist college that was associated with a church. Often the musicians would be in the back-up band for big time Nashville Gospel artists. 
    The guy who was playing timpani said that he could control the crowd by how he played the timpani.  I didn’t believe him.  He said, “You know _____’s signature song, the one that everyone always responds to with standing ovations and cheers? I will just put a plain drum roll on it at the end, with no crescendo and no stinger. Likewise, on this other song (a real sleeper), I will put a drum roll on it with a stinger.  Observe what happens.”  Lo and behold!  The signature song received polite applause and the “ordinary” song received s thunderous, long standing ovation.
     
    It is true that music moves the heart and soul.  There is a fine line between worshipping and entertaining.  We could get into the conversation about why shouldn’t worship be entertaining.  However, when I began to look at the way the church manipulated people through music, histrionics, etc., I realized for myself that what was going on was not “edification” nor “woship of the Divine.”
     
    I’ve since moved to the other side of the spectrum and the silence of Quaker worship appeals to me greatly, where a song that comes out of silence seems to be a more appropriate worship.
     
    Log in to Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

  • ACDA.org
  • The ChoralNet Daily Newsletter

Advertise on ChoralNet

Footer

Connect with us!

  • Home
  • About
  • Help
  • Contact Us
  • ACDA.org

Recent Blogs

  • Choral Ethics: April is Autism Awareness Month
  • Choral Ethics: Almost There
  • The Conductor as Yogi: Take What You Need
  • Choral Ethics: Busy Times
  • ChoralEd, Basic Audio Setup

American Choral Directors Association

PO Box 1705
Oklahoma City, Oklahoma
73101-1705

© 2026 American Choral Directors Association. All rights reserved.
Terms of Use | Privacy Policy