• Sign In
  • ACDA.org
  • Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
ChoralNet

ChoralNet

The professional networking site for the global online choral community.

  • Home
  • Blog
  • ACDA News
  • Events
  • Community
    • Announcements
    • Classifieds

You are here: Home / Others / Extreme Rehearsal Makeover

Extreme Rehearsal Makeover

September 10, 2010 by Tim Sharp Leave a Comment


When asked, “What are the three most important characteristics that a conductor possesses?” research tells us enthusiasm (26%), confidence (21%), and authority (17%) are the traits most highly valued by our singers.
 
As we enter our fall rehearsal schedules and start ramping up again with a fresh beginning, why not do an extreme makeover for your rehearsal style that emphasizes these traits?  Expectations are high in the fall, so it is a good time to meet or exceed them. The following ideas could be helpful toward such a makeover:
  • If you are in a new ensemble setting, take a video camera to the rehearsal to film everyone saying their name and “one unforgettable thing" you should know about them,  so you can memorize names and capture a little of their personality by the next rehearsal. This demonstrates your desire to get to know the singers.  Then, do it.  Work with a chart at your first rehearsal and the following rehearsals if necessary to aid your memory.  This may be the most important thing that you do in your first days with any new ensemble.  Nothing is more important than knowing the names of the performers.  This is work, but it is important work.  I have made this the top priority of every new setting I am in.  People love nothing more than hearing their own name.
  • Project or distribute a detailed, complete rehearsal plan at the start of the rehearsal to show the ensemble you are extremely organized and have a plan.  The point of giving your plan to the ensemble is so they will see what you have been thinking about, and what details you are going to work on in this rehearsal.  The discipline is good for you, and the respect for your work ethic, along with your prompting, will encourage the ensemble to make the markings you have outlined on the rehearsal plan during the times in the rehearsal you are working with other sections. No ensemble respects disorganization.  In fact, nothing undoes them like an unorganized leader.  In fact, in your makeover, organize everything in the rehearsal room that can be organized, and insist this is your new style.  Communicate organization. As performers begin talking about your new look, don’t be happy until you hear the comments coming back to you that you are the most organized person they have ever seen. 
  • Prepare a new component such as a projected outline of the next program, a short demo of a piece of music you intend to program, or a unique way of making announcements, to show the choir that along with your detailed rehearsal plan, you are in control of the present and future plans. Your ensemble has the need to be certain you are the authority, and that you intend to kindly use authority for the good of the ensemble.  By planning a new component to the rehearsal, you show that you are the architect for the rehearsal hour.
  • Do not do anything in the rehearsal that is not written out for the ensemble, so that they see you are a communicator as well as a planner.  Either project the information, hand it out, or put lists on the wall if that is the best you can do, but the point is to use whatever methods are available to demonstrate as many layers of written communication as possible.  Make the ensemble believe you are the best communicator in the world. If you have a website, Facebook page, or whatever, make it a part of your rehearsal outline routine, and further, have the material on that site just before the "real time" rehearsal begins so you can refer to it during rehearsal for later reference.
  • Work through everything on your rehearsal sheet that you handed out to the ensemble to show you are calm, ordered, and that order is something they too can calmly anticipate.  There is something about having these markings and musical desires written down that will keep anyone from saying, “we didn’t do it that way before.”  And, like a map, they signal there is a path to where you want to go. The rehearsal sheet brings another level of authority to the rehearsal for you, and working through all of the items on the list demonstrates careful planning. 
  • Document the traditions, the logistic requirements for performances, and other routines to which the ensemble is accustomed, and have those written out and placed on an announcement board.  You can tell the ensemble you want all newcomers to be familiar with these procedures, but the reality is they will also underscore the same procedures for veterans, and for you to remember as well.  Verbal announcements are okay, but be sure they are also written out on a rehearsal sheet.  If you can have the next performance list ready, hand it out for them to see during the rehearsal.  All this writing will demonstrate to the ensemble how much you care about communication.
  • Memorize the music you are working on for the rehearsal, and rarely look down at the score so that you can look your ensemble members in the eye as you convey your passion for the music.  Be prepared, demonstrate that you are prepared, and build their trust in you as someone that is prepared and wants to communicate.  Every time we look at the music, we communicate some degree of insecurity to the choir, no matter how subtle the look is.  In contrast, if you never look down, you may never communicate insecurity. What you want to communicate is authority. If memorization is not possible in the early rehearsals, choose music you know very well for the first rehearsal to aid in your ability to look up.
  • Plan for one surprise in the rehearsal as a moment of “planned spontaneity” to show the ensemble what they can look forward to each week as a part of your style of leadership.  For example, introduce your family to the ensemble; do something comical that no one knows you can do; give away ice cream coupons to everyone that is on tome; read a note from a former director that introduces you to the ensemble. One activity I planned for such a first rehearsal was to read a message from the composer of one of the pieces we were rehearsing.  This was a simple process to achieve.  I simply emailed a note to the composer asking for a few words about the piece.  It was no problem for the composer to send a few sentences back to me electronically, with a couple of personal words to the ensemble.
Built upon a solid core of musicianship, the effective conductor establishes a foundation of enthusiasm, confidence, and authority, and also works to further create an atmosphere of honesty, transparency, encouragement, and friendship, all within an ensemble environment that intensely pursues the shared task of musical accomplishment and the pursuit of perfection.
 
 

 

 

 

Filed Under: Others

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. Marie Grass Amenta says

    September 16, 2010 at 8:28 pm

    These are wonderful ideas and will try to impliment a few, myself.  I have wanted to contact the composer of one of our fall concert pieces but was worried about disturbing him–I will get on it right now!
     
    I already give my choir a rehearsal plan, most of the time detailed but, sometimes general.  I actually email my rehearsal plan every week to my chamber choir, five days before our weekly rehearsal.  This give them time to practice. In addition to showing them I am organized, it also show them I respect their time.  Instead of practicing all the music for every concert, they can focus on just what we are going to rehearse.  Working with busy adults, showing respect for their time has proven to be a deciding factor often when a  scheduling conflict between groups arises.
     
    I will work on those other ideas. Thanks for your always wonderful insights!
     
    Marie
    Log in to Reply
  2. Tim Sharp says

    September 14, 2010 at 10:15 am

    Bob, Good insights. Actually, the research makes the point that the characteristics you describe are assumed under the conductor’s enthusiasm (passion), authority, and confidence. These desired traits come after the solid foundation you are describing is constructed. The dissertation on which I base this opening statement is The Conductor and the Ensemble-From a Psychological Aspect
    Pi-Hua Chuang, DMA Dissertation, 2005, University of Maryland. Chuang does a good job of establishing the point of a solid core of musicianship. Her research looks into these “psychological” traits.

     
     
    Log in to Reply
  3. Gary Weidenaar says

    September 14, 2010 at 8:23 am

    Tim – these are GREAT ideas!
     
    Here are a couple more: 
     
    Have a seathing chart on the wall – ask them to find their seat (even in an ensemble you’ve never seen,  To make it easier, folders with their music can be laid out on the chairs in numerical order – and they have a number already assigned them.  Now they have a seat and a folder . . .  A seating chart the first day gives you a reference and chance to refer to them by name from minute 1.  It can always be changed tomorrow if you need to.
     
    If it’s an auditioned ensemble, if  the audition included learning an exerpt of a piece  – start with that piece.  They already know it – so you can work on something more than notes or rhythm the first day.
    Log in to Reply
  4. Robert Eaton says

    September 14, 2010 at 7:24 am

    Interesting that neither musicianship nor empathy-sensitivity (interpesonal relationships) are among the valued characteristics. Perhaps this a commentary on the artistic and musical awareness of the vocalists  but it does explain why some conductors who are decidely arrogant, egotistical, and autocratic are perceived by the establishment to be successful.  Their vocalists do it the ‘conductor’s way,’ like robots, with little or no personal committment to the art in which they are participating.  My preference is for a choir that is musical, with each individual committed to the text, music, expression, and meaning of that which they are communicating, rather than the ‘perfect’ choir that dutifully mimics a director.  I know there are many, better than I, who are able to achieve both, perfection and artistry, but all too often, confidence (ego), and authority subsume the music.
    Bob Eaton

    “The most important thing about performing is to make magic, to make a special moment in time.  The whole process … is never about proving something but about sharing something.”
    Yo Yo Ma
    Log in to Reply
  5. Jennifer Whiting says

    September 14, 2010 at 5:11 am

    Dr. Tim, thank you for these excellent challenges and inspiring ideas!
    Log in to Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

  • ACDA.org
  • The ChoralNet Daily Newsletter

Advertise on ChoralNet

Footer

Connect with us!

  • Home
  • About
  • Help
  • Contact Us
  • ACDA.org

Recent Blogs

  • Choral Ethics: Perfectly Calm
  • The Conductor as Yogi: From Summer Re-Set to Life Practice
  • Choral Ethics: Mother’s Day–Songs My Mother Taught Me
  • ChoralEd: Secondary Choral Ensemble Auditions
  • Choral Ethics: MayDay

American Choral Directors Association

PO Box 1705
Oklahoma City, Oklahoma
73101-1705

© 2025 American Choral Directors Association. All rights reserved.
Terms of Use | Privacy Policy