What If....the classroomDate: March 26, 2012 Views: 3886
Colleagues,
I was recently asked this question that I typically discourage amongst my students. What if? What if you could have or do anything to your teaching space? What would you want? No ya buts, just what ifs. I'm not sure this is a question I have the answer to, or if I did answer I wouldn't want to adapt after living in a what if scenario. So I pose this question to you. What if? Would you stick to tradition or break away. Even if you were given permission to try and fail, what would you need, change, or do. I hope you'll give me your two cents as I am genuinely curious and exploring how I could better run my program for a 21st century audience.
Replies (16): Threaded | Chronological
Amalie Hinson on March 26, 2012 7:59pm
Hi Robert,
You do not mention your teaching situation. As a music instructor at a community college, I would add an Orff ensemble. It would offer opportunities to both the accomplished musician and the beginner. I have seen Orff process work with students this age many, many times. And it would definitely appeal to an audience that is increasingly interested in music outside of the Western art tradition.
Amalie W. Hinson
on March 26, 2012 8:12pm
Robert: A very interesting question, but the only possible answer is that it would depend entirely on what KIND of ensemble I was directing at the time. And not everyone has a "typical" ensemble or group of ensembles.
I directed a show ensemble here for 14 years, and one for several years before that at another university. We needed rehearsal space with a dance floor, dance mirrors, a practice stage set, and good sound equipment for realistic rehearsals, as well as space to rehearse with the showband. At this school we had them; at the previous school we did not, just multipurpose classroom/rehearsal rooms.
I also directed an early music ensemble at the other school, and am now directing one here. That calls for an entirely different kind of space and entirely different equipment, as you might expect. A live room would be nice, as well as harpsichords and perhaps organs for rehearsal. Here we have the latter, but not the former. And this is typical of rooms used for multiple purposes.
Our traditional choral ensembles rehearse in the same Recital Salon in which they normally perform, which in many ways is ideal. The ensembles at the other school did not, and could not, because at the time there was only one Recital Hall and it was booked morning to late night, so only one dress rehearsal was ever possible, and not always at an ideal time. And of course larger ensembles almost always have to perform in places other than where they rehearse.
All the best,
John
on March 27, 2012 9:16am
Forgive the potential threadjack, but I have to ask...why do
you discourage this question among your students?
Margot
on March 27, 2012 2:30pm
Great point...I wonder that myself. Typically as a time saving measure but not when it comes to exploration. More so along the lines of "You are required to attend the concert..." but "What if......my car blows up?" Those are the sort of what if questions I usually get, so thats why I said that.
on March 27, 2012 8:09pm
Fair enough. Though, I had a teacher in high school (and
again later as a pro) who would have said "In that case, I expect
you to put your shoes on and run here! And be on time! No
excuses!".
You know who you are.
on March 27, 2012 8:15pm
Oh, and I would want more space (enough to get them moving
around with having to move furniture), better AV equipment, the
possibility of a music stand for every singer (I have this at one
job, and it's great) . I am lucky enough to have gorgeous (I mean,
really) performance spaces, and crew (!!) for each concert, so
that's something I don't have to wish for...but believe me,
professional lighting and stage managing makes a big
difference!
on March 27, 2012 3:41pm
I have thought about this regularly. For my current ensemble I would want:
1. A set of dressing rooms , uniform racks, garment bags, character shoes, and uniform jewelry.
2. A soundshell
3. An actual auditorium to perform in.
4. Sound equipment to make quality recordings, and a quality camera to tape performances and rehearsals. Good condenser microphones. Also a way to just plug it in and immedietly watch/listen to it.
5. A charter bus all our own like athletics.
6. To not have to share my space with band and orchestra.
7. A much bigger music budget.
8. An accompanist.
on March 28, 2012 5:29am
I would get rid of the desks and buy music stands for each singer, so all could stand and move as the music required.
I would have a big screen on which to project images and sight singing clips.
I would have a storage area for singers to keep their choral music.
I would have a fine recording system to play examples of excellent singing. I would show youtube clips on my big screen.
I would find a way to record all the choral parts on youtube and have singers view the score on youtube while hearing their parts as they watch.
Jura
on March 29, 2012 7:11am
Being a realist, I look at this question and instead of saying "What if" I ask "What Can". As artists we need to realize that we will always have a battle to face, whether it be through the music we sing or how we receive our funding. Instead of listing what you want, why not take that list and prioritize it in order of importance, and start fundraising. It's fun to play with your imagination, and play the "What if" game, but music did not evolve by playing the "What if" game. I'm sorry if I am a Debby Downer, but instead of becoming discouraged by thinking about what you don't have, start thinking about how you can get the things you need.
I Hope This Helps,
Jamie
on March 29, 2012 8:12am
The list I posted above is what is still on my to-do list.
This year I crossed off uniforms and folio cabinets.
Garment bags and sound shell are my projects for next year, enrollment will hopefully cause a big enough issue to force a fix on the shared space.
Little bit at a time. Win a contest = ask for something, increase enrollment = ask for something.
Sadly my kids are not that great at the fundraising. It pays for t-shirts (poor district so no choir fees), uniform alterations/cleaning, & additional travel.
Dreaming doesn't hurt a thing, dream huge.
on March 29, 2012 11:12am
Like I said before, I'm a realist, it was just my point of view. I did not by any means want to offend or upset anyone in anyway. I agree, imagination is a very vital thing to us as Directors, Performers, etc. But I personally get discouraged when I start listing the things I don't have that I want, and the program needs! I'm happy that you were able to start crossing those things off the list, and that your program is moving forward! I just try to use fundraising as an option to keep those necessities coming. I hope that your program continues to grow!
on March 29, 2012 9:04am
There is not enough space in this to type all my wants! Bigger room, Music, Folders, uniforms, Performance space, bus, etc. etc. etc. It seems like an uphill battle everyday in public music education. I love to dream! Thanks for letting me!
JoAnn Barker
Owasso 8th Grade Choir
Owasso Community Choir
on March 29, 2012 4:55pm
JoAnn et al.: Equipment--"stuff" in Lori's words--can be prioritized, fundraised, and graduatlly acquired. Been there, done that, big time! And that goes back to when I was in high school, a LONG time ago, and got to help my dad figure out how to spend a $10,000 windfall from the School Board for the purchase and upgrade of new band instruments. (Probably the equivalent of 10 times that amout today.)
I agree with Lori that choral programs can accomplish a huge amount without a lot of or the best "stuff," but instrumental programs are not as lucky. Still, I agree that a single inspired and inspiring teacher can make more difference than anything else.
Facilities, on the other hand, can seldom be improved unless or until new construction or re-construction takes place. And when it does, it really pays to get in on the planning and put in the endless work that it involves, because that's the only way to make sure your own viewpoint is well represented. The trick is to get it included in the plans, not try to wangle it after the fact. And always to ask for more than you expect to get, because once the bean-counters see the bottom line there will almost ALWAYS be cuts made. And once in a blue moon you might actually get lucky!
All the best,
John
on March 29, 2012 12:43pm
I see the question in regard to teaching. "What if...to try and fail/change.... to better run a program for the 21st century audience." An excellent program is not dependent on "stuff". The beautiful performance area is a wonderful thing, but, it is not necessary to a beautiful performance. SO.... "What if"? What if we didn't have to perform? What if we could learn and rehearse without the stress/criticism or performance. What if we were able to teach for the love of music, instead of pleasing an audience? What if all our students wanted to work, really work hard, EVERY DAY in rehearsal. What if they were always excited to come to class and give it their all..... or, more importantly, what if I was ALWAYS excited to teach class and give it MY all EVERY DAY, EVERY rehearsal. What if the kids LOVED ALL the music I present to them? What if my audience and students saw value in the art songs, rather than "I wish they/we would/could sing something I already know...."? (can you tell I teach middle/high school?) What if I didn't have to worry about discipline in the classroom? Some days the reality stinks. Some days I feel like I have nothing left to give (especially about this time of the year) Some rehearsals I think I haven't accomplished a thing..... Yet, somehow, the magic shows up. Not every day. Not only in performance. Sometimes I can walk on a cloud because of what happened in rehearsal or performance. What if I am settling? What if there is REALLY MORE!?
on April 3, 2012 6:54pm
Yes! That was so much fun and refreshing to read. The idea of project based learning is such a hot button among educators now. Not teaching to the test but to a real life experience. Well, we've been doing that all along via concerts, so to hear you say, that's not enough is exciting. So what IS enough, where are we going in the next decade to facilitate deepr learning? It seems that we can be so focused on what we need or don't have. I'm lucky enough to teach in a school that asks me to think these things and then wants to help me find the answers. I know not everyone is as fortunate as I am but we have to start moving our agenda forward and not remaining status quo. With the educational focus shifting from test prep to whole student and PBL it seems like we can become front runners in an education movement for once instead of adapting after the fact. Thank you for sharing your thoughts, and keep asking those questions and exploring the answers.
|